Improved Terrain Texture Tiling

Whenever working with highly detailed terrain textures like rock textures on the terrain, i have to face the problem of highly visible tiling.
Just approving the texture often doesn’t help at all:




Multi-UV Mixing
So i looked for other solutions and found an article about advanced terrain texturing on udn, where multi-uv mixing is shown as one very cheap method of reducing tiling just using a modified shader which mixes one texture at two different UV sizes.

Hacking the original shader and mixing the rock texture with a copy of itself at a scale of 4x reduces the tiling.




This even gives you nice results on near camera distances.




Modified shader
Edit the built in shader [or the TerrainReplacement.shader when using "UnityTerrainBump" like in the example above] and find the col-definition of the texture slot you want to use multi uv-mixing with:

Code (csharp):

1. // original shader
2. col += splat_control.b * tex2D (_Splat2, IN.uv_Splat2).rgb;
3.  

Change it to:

Code (csharp):

1.  
2. // improved shader
3. col += splat_control.b * tex2D (_Splat2, IN.uv_Splat2).rgb * tex2D (_Splat2, IN.uv_Splat2 * -0.25).rgb * 4;
4.  

Where "*-0.25" adds a 4x size with flip to the scaled texture and "*4" just brightens the color as multiplying 2 texture samples results in a darker color. Just play around with those two parameters to find the best solution.
You may also want to desaturate the result which would end up in some more instructions on the col-definitions.

I hope this will help some people to reduce tiling on the terrain and keeping highly detailed textures at the same time.

lars


Make sure you read:
http://udn.epicgames.com/Three/TerrainAdvancedTextures.html

 

Cool thank you!

 

Excelent!

Thank you.

 

Epic!

 

thanks go to epic....

 

Only drawback I see is that you cant use textures with regular shapes (bricks, mozaic, roads....). It would need more complicated implementation done on per material bases (impossible on unity, because terrain engine is not material based), or only for some channels of ARGB splat maps (probably possible).

 

@Demostenes: probably you are right as far as bricks and mozaics are concerned, but i guess that you won’t need better tiling on such textures.
and in fact you can excactly specify which channel uses Multi-UV Mixing and which one doesn’t as each splatmap has its own col-definition in the shader. just have a look at the second picture: the rock textures uses Multi-UV Mixing, the brown ground texture doesn’t.
lars

 

Nice find Lars.

 

This doesn't play well with the "base map" texture that Unity falls back to for distant terrain, but is an otherwise useful technique that also works well on large wall or cliff meshes, etc. I'm not sure if we have access to that terrain base map, but if not then it will never match the tiling, saturation, or luminosity of the rest of the terrain in Unity using this method.

edit: you'll probably want to make sure that your normal map is still normalised after tiling it over itself like this.

 

you are absolutely right mingo – unfortunately: it doesn’t work well with the automatically created basemap. and as far as i know there is no possibility to get access to the basemap in order to change it in any way.
for this reason i tend to hide the basemapped distant terrain in the fog…

 

Are you a wizard?

 

shader has been released within the the advanced terrain shader package v2 [free!] on the asset store.
see: http://forum.unity3d.com/threads/119127-Coming-soon-Advanced-terrain-shaders-%96-Volume-2 for further details.

lars

 

Tiling of textures on cliffs was irritating me too, spolied some nice landscapes i'd made and although larger rock textures looked good at a distance, up close they were bad.

This is an ideal solution, exactly what I needed to get rid of that problem... thank you.

 

This is really great. I will have to hop over and give it a test.

Regards,
Matt.

 

thanks. i hope this will help you to improve the look of your terrains.
i have just pushed the terrain shaders a bit further, so it now supports better tiling even on textures like grass or sand.

and make sure you check the ats v2 shader package [free]: http://forum.unity3d.com/threads/119127-Coming-soon-Advanced-terrain-shaders-%96-Volume-2



lars

 

very nice

 

indeed ;-)
and it offers much more possibilities if you have just some more texture memory left: think of missapplying the alpha channel to add low frequency disturbance!
[right now it is only a greyscaled/ low contrast/ upscaled version of the the original rgb terrain texture ]

lars

 

More than perfect these shaders...

I know that it is not fair but you are saying that is more possibilites how to improve it. Can you prepare better shaders? For the best quality. For me shaders are too hard .

But perfect job anyway!

 

it's really awesome!
However, how can I make textures which tile correctly?

 

99,999th comment! Woohoo!

 

After playing with the shaders, I noticed something...

Instead of:

Splat * Tex1 * Tex2 * 4

you can use:

Splat * 0.5 * (Tex1 + Tex2)

This should give exact average between the two textures rather than the unpredictable contrast-distortion caused by the multiply operator - you can then ditch the arbitrary multiplier on the end.

 

you are absolutely right. but using Splat * 0.5 * (Tex1 + Tex2) usually does not produce such a lively mixture. so it is up to anybody just to test different operators to get the best result for a given texture.

lars

 

I don't understand how to add other texture slots. it's only using the first.

 

Very true, I agree with you there that the contrast boost does actually look good with the right textures and numbers applied and stops the dulling caused by a true average mix.

On the subject of the basemap problems some people have had - do you think it would help doing the big version of the texture first and doing UV*-4 rather than UV*-0.25) - so the big version is first (and the basemap would then be based on that I assume?!?) and the smaller version would still be mixed in the same when viewed close (when the splatmap is used instead of the basemap)?

I've not tried yet, so it's just a theory... but it seems logical to me

 

I posted a version in the other thread that lets you use all 4 slots, and control how much they mix, if you want to try that one:

Modified Terrain shaders

It's probably a little bit heaver than the current version, but it's better than using 8 texture slots just to mix up the tiling.

 

i guess the modified shader is completely ignored when generating the basemap – so this would not help i think.
but using Splat * 0.5 * (Tex1 + Tex2) should already give you a fitting basemap doesn’t it?
using Splat * Tex1 * Tex2 * 4 will probably never end up in a correct basemap for it would not contain the contrast strech produced by the multiplication.

lars

 

Well, I tested it (what better way to find out?!)

If you put the larger version first the basemap will use the features that are visible at a further distance... so it does help... however, it drops out the 2nd texture - so... it also has a side-effect...

The two options are:
1) Large texture used primarily and have shader scale tiling up (so 2nd texture is smaller) = basemap appears to retain the texture featires visible at the furthest distance - but it appears to sharpen those features up as the "noise" of the 2nd texture is omitted.



2) Small texture used primarily and have shader scale tiling down (so 2nd texture is larger) = basemap appears to retain the texture features visible close-up - so majority of texture perceivable at that distance is dropped and what would be the normal tightly-tiled texture is what is used on the basemap.



Although you're using the multiply method which will give different results - I think the basemap issue will be the same sort of thing.

 

@Syanyde: well, that sounds pretty good!
well done!

lars

 

How do you change the builtin terrain shader? Also tried with the atsV2 and tiling is clearly visible in the demo.

 

Just give a shader the same name as a Unity built in shader.

 

I can't get this to work when switching to Android platform. I've tried maxing the settings in both quality and player settings (Android 4, ARMv7, OpenGL ES 2.0). But I still just get the basemap. Any ideas?

 

How do i make it so more than just the first texture does the tile mixing?

 

Nice discovery.

 

Thanks for this Lars (and Syanyde), really improves the terrain visual quality!

 

To do this with unity 5 shaders, theres a function called SplatmapMix in the file CGIncludes/TerrainSplatmapCommon.cginc - you can make a copy of this function, modify it, and put it in your own shader file. Doing the Tex1 * Tex2 * 4 makes my textures very overexposed, same goes with the bump map. So the 0.5 * (Tex1 + Tex2) gives a useable end result

 

ZeddZedd,

I have located the mentioned file, and found the associated function, I must be doing something wrong though, because I am not seeing changes (even with restart). Can you post your edited code block please?

 

@EternalApps ive made a copy of the original shader, and called it something custom, then created a material that uses that shader, and then created terrrain that uses that material. Im guessing the acutal assignment of materials/shader here is the problem since youre not seeing any changes at all

The actual modified code is as follows

Code (CSharp):

1.  
2.           #ifdef _TERRAIN_NORMAL_MAP
3.                 fixed4 nrm = 0.0f;
4.                 nrm += splat_control.r * .5 * (tex2D(_Normal0, IN.uv_Splat0) + tex2D(_Normal0, IN.uv_Splat0 * -.25));
5.                 nrm += splat_control.g * .5 * (tex2D(_Normal1, IN.uv_Splat1) + tex2D(_Normal1, IN.uv_Splat1 * -.25));
6.                 nrm += splat_control.b * .5 * (tex2D(_Normal2, IN.uv_Splat2) + tex2D(_Normal2, IN.uv_Splat2 * -.25));
7.                 nrm += splat_control.a * .5 * (tex2D(_Normal3, IN.uv_Splat3) + tex2D(_Normal3, IN.uv_Splat3 * -.25));
8.                 mixedNormal = UnpackNormal(nrm);
9.             #endif
10.            
11.             mixedDiffuse = 0.0f;
12.             mixedDiffuse += splat_control.r * .5 * (tex2D(_Splat0, IN.uv_Splat0) + tex2D(_Splat0, IN.uv_Splat0 * -.25));
13.             mixedDiffuse += splat_control.g * .5 * (tex2D(_Splat1, IN.uv_Splat1) + tex2D(_Splat1, IN.uv_Splat1 * -.25));
14.             mixedDiffuse += splat_control.b * .5 * (tex2D(_Splat2, IN.uv_Splat2) + tex2D(_Splat2, IN.uv_Splat2 * -.25));
15.             mixedDiffuse += splat_control.a * .5 * (tex2D(_Splat3, IN.uv_Splat3) + tex2D(_Splat3, IN.uv_Splat3 * -.25));

 

Yes, but for those kinds of textures, tiling looks more natural with much less effort if you can find decent textures to start with.

 

Thanks! This technique drastically improved the look of my terrain. Thank you very much!

 

This looks exactly to what am looking for,

Has any1 tested this correctly on Unity5?
if so, how?

Can any devs put this into a proyect example?

Thanks!

 

Hi,

I've created an asset that could help with the terrain tiling problem.
You can check it here: UV Mixxer

 

Thanks for this technique, it came in handy for me.

Here's it applied to the Unity standard terrain shader for 2018.4.2f1 which may be a useful starting point for people.

 

Hello
i am new in unity
if i give you a mesh terrain shader can you please modify it ?

 

Unfortunately, they only work with Unity 2018.
Any solutions for Unity 2019? I'm not an expert in shaders so I don't know how to modify it.