Swapping Override Clips at Runtime

Hey guys!

I have a base AnimatorController and an AnimatorOverrideController.

Things work well except for when I swap out the override AnimationClip from the list of AnimationClipPairs at runtime! It resets the animator controller

overrideController[originalClipName] = attackClip;

That is all I have written for the swap and it results in the entire animator being reset. It goes back to its default state and all parameters are reset.

Is there a way that I can somehow safely swap the clip and keep the current state I am in as well as the parameters? (The state I am in is not the state that I want to swap the clip for)

 

Hi Alismuffin,

It's expected that the animator is resetted when you change a clip. This is something we would like to change in the future.

In the meantime you need to save the Animator State before changing the clip, change the clip and then push back the saved state.

Code (CSharp):

1.        
2.         Animator animator = GetComponent<Animator>();
3.  
4.         AnimatorStateInfo[] layerInfo = new AnimatorStateInfo[animator.layerCount];
5.         for (int i = 0; i < animator.layerCount; i++)
6.         {
7.             layerInfo[i] = animator.GetCurrentAnimatorStateInfo(i);
8.         }
9.  
10.         // Do swap clip in override controller here
11.  
12.         // Push back state
13.         for (int i = 0; i < animator.layerCount; i++)
14.         {
15.             animator.Play(layerInfo[i].nameHash, i, layerInfo[i].normalizedTime);
16.         }
17.        
18.         // Force an update
19.         animator.Update(0.0f);
20.  

 

Hey thanks that helps a lot!

However that still doesn't solve my issue with the actual parameters changing. I have a float value that I need to stay the same during the clip change. Is there any similar solution to this?

 

yes you will need to save the parameter value too.

 

As far as I can see there is no way of getting a list of these parameters which makes that solution not entirely ideal. I can't rely on knowing the names of the parameters that I want to save because this is a very generic operation I am doing.

Thanks to your initial post and some reworking of my controller I was able to get what I wanted without making use of parameters so thanks for that!

 

In 5.0 we did add Animator.parameters which return the parameter list.

 

Ah! That's great. Unfortunately I cannot use 5.0 at this point but that is great to know! Thanks for your help.

 

How were you able to overcome the problem without the solutions mecanim.dev suggested?

 

I'm using Mechanim.Dev's solution ( as well as manually resetting some of my basic controller bools) but I'm now getting this error in the console:

Calling Animator.GotoState on Synchronize layer

This appears to be happening when I call animator.Play() in the 'push back state' block in the example code, and the effect is that my replacement clips don't play.

Could this be due to the fact that I'm calling this inside a coroutine?

 

Also, I just wanted to clarify how Unity 5 will improve this. Will Unity 5 eliminate the need for us to manually save/restore the state, or will it only make it easier for us to save/restore the state ourselves?

 

We didn't change anything regarding this in 5.0, you still need to save/restore everything manually

 

Check this out awesome example https://github.com/nonehill/DynamicallyLoadingAnimation It reduce memory usage in my 2d game from 800mb to 120 mb in runtime. Load and Unload animations whatever you need at runtime

 

Hi,
I've been trying this on a simple test in 5.1.1 and it doesn't seem to work anymore (or I'm doing something wrong). After saving the states and changing the clips through the override controller, the original Animator becomes corrupt it seems, reporting 0 layers and 0 parameters. No error is raised and the clip replacement works, but the states are not restored correctly and so the FSM resets.

Any idea what's going on?

 

Hi Ben_SEM,
i think i found the solution to your problem with the resetting FSM:

Code (CSharp):

1. Animator animator = GetComponent<Animator>();
2. AnimatorStateInfo[] layerInfo = new AnimatorStateInfo[animator.layerCount];
3. for (int i = 0; i < animator.layerCount; i++)
4. {
5.     layerInfo[i] = animator.GetCurrentAnimatorStateInfo(i);
6. }
7. // Do swap clip in override controller here
8.  
9. // Force an update
10. animator.Update(0.0f);
11.  
12. // Push back state
13. for (int i = 0; i < animator.layerCount; i++)
14. {
15.     animator.Play(layerInfo[i].nameHash, i, layerInfo[i].normalizedTime);
16. }      
17.  

As you can see, i moved the animator.Update(0.0f) line right before the // Push back state and it seems to work just fine for me.

 

It works for me as well! Thanks a lot riccardo

 

I'm glad it worked for you too! You're welcome

 

Two more things to know if you're trying to pull this one:
1- spinning the animator *again* (though animator.Update(0f)) after restoring the animator state prevents some cases of one-frame undetermined state
2 - backing up and restoring the animator parameters as well is a good idea. See http://answers.unity3d.com/questions/919995/parameters-and-states-of-animator-reset-on-objects.html. Note that I don't know of any way to save and restore the *trigger* parameters, which due to the way we build our animators is not an issue for us; but that may be a blocking point for others.
[Edit: more points!]
3 - restoring the state of the animator does not restore transitions (blends) that were in progress. Haven't found a way to do that properly, though maybe using CrossFade could help.

 

Animator.layercount returns 0 for me when I use an animator controller override in 2020.2.2f1, and it also says animator doesnt have an animator controller when it clearly does

 

Either post a thread about it and give some actual details or report a bug in Unity via the Help menu. Don't necro a 6 year old thread just because it's tangentially related.